音乐里的悲伤,AI永远复制不了

近年来,人工智能技术的发展也开始渗透到艺术领域,能够模仿风格作画吟诗,爆款歌曲信手拈来。这引发了许多人的思考:当技术能复制形式时,它能否真正替代那些源于真实生命经历的情感表达?那些打动我们的作品,其核心力量是否正来自于人类独有的喜怒哀乐?我们马上和 Lala 一起走进今天的文章。

讲解人 · Lala

职业双语播音员 资深美音口语培训师

原文


        
** Grief inspired the year's best music — something AI won't ever feel **
The most acclaimed albums of 2025 make for impressively eclectic listening.

But it’s hard not to notice how similar they are thematically: a large swathe of the Guardian’s albums of the year seem consumed by loss.

There are straightforward explorations of failed relationships: for all its religious imagery, there’s a prosaic breakup at the heart of Rosalía’s Lux,

while West End Girl’s lurid detailing of the collapse of Lily Allen’s marriage kept the tabloids in headlines for weeks.

Death, collapsed relationships, the passing of youth and the inexorable passage of time: these are sombre themes that fit a quite spectacularly grim year.

But in the broader context of what’s happening to music, these albums about loss are, oddly, cause for optimism.

Among 2025’s panoply of reasons to be fearful for the future lurked the ongoing advance of AI: certainly, this was the year the technology really made an impact on popular music.

In July came the Velvet Sundown, a gently psychedelic Americana band that amassed millions of streams and were eventually revealed to be “a synthetic music project guided by human creative direction and composed, voiced and visualised with the support of artificial intelligence”.

The same month, an AI-generated facsimile of a Brazilian disco track, Predator de Perereca by Blow Records, went viral on TikTok, amassing nearly 50m streams.

This is all clearly the thin end of the wedge: there’s evidently plenty more to come.

But if AI can make a fair copy of an old disco track, or a country record or a Jorja Smith song, the one thing it can’t do is experience the kind of human emotions that power the albums above.

带着问题听讲解

  • 如何理解 acclaimed 这个词?
  • 2025 年最受好评的专辑都有哪些阴郁的主题?
  • 2025 对于 AI 音乐来说意味着什么?

讲解


        
** 音乐里的悲伤,AI永远复制不了 **
The most acclaimed albums of 2025 make for impressively eclectic listening.
2025 年最受好评的专辑,在聆听体验上呈现出令人印象深刻的多样性。
But it's hard not to notice how similar they are thematically: a large swathe of the Guardian's albums of the year seem consumed by loss. There are straightforward explorations of failed relationships: for all its religious imagery, there's a prosaic breakup at the heart of Rosalía's Lux, while West End Girl's lurid detailing of the collapse of Lily Allen's marriage kept the tabloids in headlines for weeks.
但很难不注意到,它们在主题上的相似之处:《卫报》年度专辑榜单中,有相当大一部分似乎都被“失去”所笼罩。其中有对失败关系的直白探讨:罗莎莉亚(Rosalía)的 Lux 虽然充满宗教意象,但其核心却是一段平凡而现实的分手;而 West End Girl 对莉莉·艾伦(Lily Allen)婚姻破裂的露骨描写,则让小报连续数周占据头条。
Death, collapsed relationships, the passing of youth and the inexorable passage of time: these are sombre themes that fit a quite spectacularly grim year. But in the broader context of what's happening to music, these albums about loss are, oddly, cause for optimism.
死亡、关系的崩塌、青春的流逝,以及时间不可逆转的推进——这些阴郁的主题,与这一年格外惨淡的现实十分契合。但若放在音乐行业整体变化的更大背景中来看,这些关于失去的专辑,却反而令人感到一种奇妙的乐观。
Among 2025's panoply of reasons to be fearful for the future lurked the ongoing advance of AI: certainly, this was the year the technology really made an impact on popular music.
在 2025 年种种令人对未来心生忧虑的因素中,人工智能的持续推进潜伏其间:可以说,这正是 AI 真正开始对流行音乐产生实质性影响的一年。
In July came the Velvet Sundown, a gently psychedelic Americana band that amassed millions of streams and were eventually revealed to be "a synthetic music project guided by human creative direction and composed, voiced and visualised with the support of artificial intelligence".
7 月,一支名为 Velvet Sundown 的温和迷幻美式民谣乐队出现,迅速积累了数百万次播放量,随后被揭示为“一个由人类创意方向引导、在人工智能支持下完成作曲、演唱与视觉呈现的合成音乐项目”。
The same month, an AI-generated facsimile of a Brazilian disco track, Predator de Perereca by Blow Records, went viral on TikTok, amassing nearly 50m streams.
同一个月,一首由 AI 生成、模仿巴西迪斯科风格的歌曲——Blow Records 出品的 Predator de Perereca——在 TikTok 上走红,播放量接近 5000 万次。
This is all clearly the thin end of the wedge: there's evidently plenty more to come. But if AI can make a fair copy of an old disco track, or a country record or a Jorja Smith song, the one thing it can't do is experience the kind of human emotions that power the albums above.
这一切显然只是楔子的一端:可以预见,接下来还会有更多类似的作品出现。但即便 AI 能够相当逼真地复制一首老式迪斯科歌曲、一张乡村专辑,或是一首“乔娅·史密斯式”的作品,它仍然无法做到的一点是——去亲身体验那些驱动上述专辑创作的、真正的人类情感。

重点词汇

grief

/ɡriːf/

n. 悲伤;悲痛;忧伤

  • 近义词:sadness; sorrow
    英文释义:very great sadness, especially at the death of someone
    例句:She couldn't cope with the grief she felt inside.

acclaimed

/əˈkleɪmd/

adj. 备受赞誉的;广受好评的

  • 搭配短语:critically acclaimed
    搭配短语:highly acclaimed

make for
有助于;促成;导致

  • 例句:The contradictions in his character make for a compelling story.

eclectic

/ɪˈklek.tɪk/

adj. 折衷的;兼收并蓄的;风格多样的

  • 词根词缀:lect-(选择、采集)
    例句:My taste in music is quite eclectic.
    搭配短语eclectic style

thematically

/θɪˈmæt.ɪ.kəl.i/

adv. 在主题上;从主题角度

  • 例句:The pictures were arranged thematically.

swathe

/swɑːð/

n. 一长条;大片

  • 例句:The storm destroyed a huge swathe of the forest.
    搭配短语:a large swathe of the population

prosaic

/proʊˈzeɪ.ɪk/

adj. 平淡乏味的;缺乏想象力的

  • 英文释义:without interest, imagination, and excitement
    搭配短语:a prosaic life
    搭配短语:a prosaic explanation

lurid

/ˈlʊr.ɪd/

adj. 骇人的;耸人听闻的;色彩刺眼的

  • 搭配短语lurid headlines
    搭配短语lurid details

tabloid

/ˈtæb.lɔɪd/

n. 小报;八卦媒体

inexorable

/ɪˈnek.sər.ə.bəl/

adj. 不可阻挡的;无情推进的

  • 搭配短语:the inexorable passage of time
    搭配短语:the inexorable logic of history
    搭配短语:the inexorable rise of AI

sombre

/ˈsɑːm.bɚ/

adj. 阴沉的;严肃的;忧郁的

  • 例句:This is a sombre occasion.

grim

/ɡrɪm/

adj. 严峻的;冷酷的;令人沮丧的

  • 搭配短语grim reality
    搭配短语grim determination

panoply

/ˈpæn.ə.pli/

n. 全套;大量;一系列

  • 搭配短语:a panoply of choices
    搭配短语:a panoply of stars

lurk

/lɝːk/

v. 潜伏;暗藏;悄然存在

  • 例句:Someone was lurking in the shadows.

psychedelic

/ˌsaɪ.kəˈdel.ɪk/

adj. 迷幻的;致幻的;迷幻风格的

Americana

/əˌmer.ɪˈkɑː.nə/

n. 美国传统文化风格(尤指音乐、艺术)

amass

/əˈmæs/

v. 积累;聚集(大量)

  • 搭配短语amass a fortune
    搭配短语amass evidence

facsimile

/fækˈsɪm.ə.li/

n. 复制品;摹本

  • 搭配短语:a facsimile of the original manuscript
    缩写:fax

the thin end of the wedge
事态恶化的开端;危险趋势的开始

  • 英文释义:the beginning of a harmful development
    例句:That feels like the thin end of the wedge.

拓展阅读

当 AI 开始制造神曲,腾讯音乐们还剩什么?
把歌手挤下榜单的 AI 音乐,正在悄悄占领你得耳朵。
每天通勤路上,酷狗音乐的资深用户田乐(化名)习惯性点开榜单,挑一首“新歌榜”或“飙升榜”里的作品当作背景音。但最近,他越来越觉得哪里“不对劲”。
“歌词都很工整,甚至有些对仗工整得不自然;旋律像在哪儿听过,但完全记不住;更关键是,声音没什么情绪。”田乐说,他试着点击歌手名查看详情,结果大多是查无此人的“空号”,甚至一天能发布十几二十首歌。
“我不是音乐专业,但我的直觉是这些歌是 AI 写的。”他的直觉正在成为一类人的共同体感,现实也验证了这一趋势。
今年 3 月,程序员 Yapie 用 DeepSeek 模型与 Make Best Music 工具,只花了数小时,就完成了《七天爱人》的词曲创作。这首基于“暗恋到分手”的提示词生成的歌曲,上线网易云音乐后,播放量迅速突破 200 万,评论超 4600 条,跻身飙升榜、赏音榜,与毛不易、陈奕迅的作品同框。
十八线音乐人拼尽全力无法战胜 AI 的调侃评价成为现实。《七天爱人》的版权最终售出数万元,将流量真实变现。这说明一件事,AI 不再只是玩具,它正在改变音乐行业的商业逻辑。
在不被告知的情况下,大众已很难分辨一首歌是否出自 AI。但对于音乐平台而言,这种模糊性正冲击其商业模式。一个供需关系正在变化:AI 的创作效率,正将音乐曲库推向理论的“无限大”,而人类的消费时间与注意力,却始终是刚性有限的。
AI 迫使音乐平台的竞争逻辑,从过去“谁拥有最多版权”的资源竞赛,转向“谁能更有效分发播放量”的运营战争。决定平台未来走向的,不再是内容多少,而是注意力的分配效率。
以上内容原载于网络,由流利说®阅读团队修改编辑。